Thursday, 23 September 2010

TripAdviser defamation suit

News of a proposed action by a group of over 400 hotels and restaurants against the review site TripAdviser will be followed with interest by internet users and legal observers alike. It has been alleged that some of the reviews posted on the TripAdvisor website contain false allegations intended to affect business and impact on reputation. If the group can show that the content posted on the website is defamatory, TripAdviser would then have to either prove the truth of the statements posted under the ‘justification’ defence or defend them on grounds of ‘fair comment’.

Fair comment is a defence commonly relied on by critics and reviewers in media. The defence applies to a statement of opinion where a review is simply giving the writer’s opinion or comment however bad this may be. The right to express opinion on matters of public interest has grown increasingly popular on the internet through various online forums, social networking sites and user reviews however the comment or criticism should be fair, honest and based on true facts. The freedom to have an opinion is entrenched in the law on human rights and the fundamental principles of freedom of speech.

To falsify and distort facts and then to comment on them as if they are true is clearly not a fair comment and the potential claimants in this action are concerned about the nature and content of what is alleged in some of the reviews.

There is however some additional protection for internet service providers hosting online forums and review sites. This is where the ISP does not have actual knowledge of the defamatory material or knowledge of the facts or circumstances from which it is apparent that the information is defamatory. If on obtaining knowledge of a defamatory statement the website fails to act expeditiously to remove or disable access to the defamatory material it will lose this protection.

Therefore TripAdviser may be required to swiftly remove material once they are given notice of any defamatory content which falsifies facts in order to avoid legal action.

Read more about Hart Brown

Wednesday, 22 September 2010

Judge says that children are damaged by divorcing parents

This morning on the BBC Breakfast News, comments made in a speech by a senior family judge, Sir Nicholas Wall were discussed.

The speech was made to the charity Families Need Fathers. In the speech, he said that parents “do not realise the damage they do to their children” and that a child’s self worth can be “irredeemably damaged” if one parent makes it clear to the child that their other parent is worthless. He also said that parents find it hard to understand that even though they have separated from their spouse, their children will still love and be loyal to both of them.

Discussing the matter this morning, Liz Edwards from Resolution said that parents don’t have enough information on how to manage their relationship with an ex-spouse going forward. Craig Pickering from Families Need Fathers advised for parents to seek help on separation.

As commented by Liz Edwards, parents should consider what they want to achieve and then consider what the effect will be on the children. Perhaps easier said than done for separating spouses when emotions are raw? However, with the support of an understanding lawyer, this can be much more achievable than one might think.

At Hart Brown, our lawyers are Resolution (which was formerly known as the Solicitors Family Law Association) accredited and we understand that separation can be a difficult time for both parents and children. We will work with you to find practical solutions and to help minimise the negative impact on children.

Link to BBC article: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-11380470

Read more about Hart Brown's Family Department

Friday, 3 September 2010

Cheryl & Ashley Cole - How quick will their divorce really be?

Today, the media are reporting that Ashley and Cheryl Cole’s divorce will be finalised in the High Court today.

However, this is not correct. The Decree Nisi will be pronounced today in court, which is the first decree in the divorce proceedings. There are two decrees in any divorce, the second one being the Decree Absolute. It is only when the Decree Absolute has been pronounced that the marriage will legally be dissolved.

There is a time delay of six weeks and one day once the Decree Nisi has been pronounced and before the Decree Absolute can be applied for by the Petitioner in the proceedings. The reason for this delay is that this is deemed to be a ‘cooling off’ period, and during this time, the parties are still legally married. The purpose of this is that it gives both parties time to consider a reconciliation. Contrary to what the media portray, a divorce is not obtained so easily in England and Wales and the court must be satisfied that there are valid reasons and that both parties have fully considered the consequences. Therefore, Ashley and Cheryl will remain married for at least another six weeks and one day!

Cheryl and Ashley’s divorce, as with many celebrity divorces is being termed by the media as a ‘quickie divorce’. However, the concept of the ‘quickie divorce’ does not exist and Cheryl and Ashley will be proceeding through exactly the same divorce process as any other couple. There is of course also the financial settlement that appears to have been negotiated which is separate to the divorce proceedings. It can take some time to reach a financial settlement, especially where there is a considerable amount of wealth.

Link to news story:-

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-11173177

Anne Thomas, Family Department, Hart Brown Solicitors

Wednesday, 25 August 2010

The Right to Strike

The London Underground can try to obtain an injunction to prevent strike action, but only if the Union has failed to comply with specific legal requirements, making the ballot and any subsequent strike unlawful. (For example the employer is entitled to know which ‘category of worker’ is being balloted. Without this precise information the employer is unable to identify the steps he may need to take to address the employees concerns or to make alternative arrangements to enable the business to function in their absence).

All employees participating in strike action are at risk. Failing to attend work is a fundamental breach of their contract of employment, and they will not be paid for days they do not work. Employees participating in unofficial strike action may be fairly dismissed. As the dismissal arises out of a breach of the employees contract they will not be entitled to notice pay. Any employee who does not work and is involved in ‘unofficial’ union action may be dismissed, even if attending meetings on their day off, or not working through fear of reprisals.

Dismissal is only automatically unfair if the employee is dismissed within 12 weeks of participating in official strike action, or the employee is absent for specific statutory or family reasons, or has been subjected to ‘selective treatment’.

Employment businesses may not provide agency workers to the employer to enable the provision of services to continue

Read more about Hart Brown's employment department

Monday, 23 August 2010

Legal aid clinical negligence work

The personal injury and clinical negligence team are delighted to confirm that their Tender for legal aid clinical negligence work has been successful.

The Legal Services Commission (LSC) who currently run legal aid notified the Team this morning to confirm the award of the Tender.

This will allow Hart Brown to continue providing legal aid services to clients who are eligible for legal aid although the Team also undertakes work for clients on a No Win No Fee basis and also under any legal expenses insurance a client may have plus traditional privately funded work.

Hart Brown has been able to offer legal aid to its clinical negligence clients who are financially eligible for many years and therefore it is a very pleasing to be able to continue to do that work where we have had some great successes most recently winning two case for severely brain injured clients which would on a lump sum basis amount to £10 million if put together.

Read more about Hart Brown's Clinical Negligence Department.

Friday, 13 August 2010

AvMA (Action against Medical Accidents) report on implementation of patient safety alerts

As some of you may have heard on the Today programme this morning the current situation in relation to patient safety alerts is nothing short of scandalous. Patient safety alerts are issued by the National Patient Safety agency to health trusts about problems that repeatedly result in injury or even death to patients which could have been avoided. Under the alerts a set of actions needs to be completed by a set deadline.

Although problems with this system were identified in an earlier report from AvMA in February 2010 as at 7 June 2010 63% of health trusts had failed to comply with at least one alert and 29 trusts had not complied with 10 or more alerts.

In relation to an alert issued on the 20 May 2004 there were still 6 instances of it not being complied with. Since a number of trusts have proved themselves capable of 100% compliance with patient safety alerts (and they are clearly to be congratulated for this) what is happening to the trusts in default? One trust for example has 23 alerts outstanding.

AvMA’s report highlights not only the problems with individual trust but with the whole system of monitoring and regulating compliance with these alerts.

For anyone with an interest in this area a full report can be found at www.avma.org.uk

To find out more about how Hart Brown can help with a clinical negligence claim, visit our website

How will a change in retirement age affect businesses?

It is worth considering the impact of the removal of the default retirement age on companies and individuals. If someone at or approaching 65 is underperforming then companies will be more inclined to follow capability procedures, and terminate for lack of capacity, whereas before they might have been prepared to wait until they could lawfully issue notice of retirement.

Companies may also ensure a retirement age is included in their contracts of employment. Alternatively, where the above does not apply, individuals who may have been looking forward to retiring at 65, may now feel morally compelled to work longer.

Removal of the default retirement age could result in increased litigation. Older people may challenge contractual retirement ages, believe they have been unfairly targeted for capability proceedings, or feel that termination for any other reason, including redundancy, is in fact age discrimination and an alternative means of terminating employment when they can no longer be forced to retire at 65. (We know that age discrimination exists, hence the difficulty for older workers seeking re-employment- removing the default retirement age will not remove the underlying problem).

Read more about Hart Brown's Employment department.