Thursday, 13 January 2011

Should Eric Illsley go to prison?

Should Eric Illsley go to prison for fiddling expenses or is community service a better option? Interestingly the public asked so far favour community service rather than prison because he is not a danger to the public, it costs the taxpayer less and he is forced to do something for the community which is visible.

Your view might depend on what you think the purpose of prison is. Is it intended to protect the public from dangerous people, punish someone by depriving them of their freedom or both? When talking about dangerous people do we mean people who threaten our physical safety or is it broader than that? Is stealing money not dangerous for those losing it? Or are we saying that Eric Illsley is not dangerous because he no longer has the opportunity to steal money or has learnt his lesson?

I am not sure a lesson needs to be learnt. Eric Illsley knew he was doing wrong. He got caught. He is responsible for setting the example. He therefore needs to set the example in terms of punishment for his crime. Whatever your view is as to what the punishment should be it should then apply to everyone else – including those stealing from their employers.

Read more here
Find our more about Hart Brown and the author of this article, Bettina Brueggemann

Wednesday, 12 January 2011

Protecting an idea?

The case of the Winklvoss twins accusing Mark Zuckerberg of stealing their idea in the creation of Facebook is news around the world and as such is equally relevant here in the UK in raising the question of whether an idea can be protected and if so how?

Under UK law the protections offered vary greatly as an idea can take many forms and it is the form that the idea takes that results in the type and level of protection that it is afforded.

To establish the protection given to an idea it needs to be established:

How is it presented?
Is it in a written or recorded form?
Is it a method or process?
Is it an item or tangible object?
How did the idea come about?
Is the idea confined to the UK, or is international protection necessary?

The underlying principle behind these questions is clear - if the idea is formally recorded either through trademark, patent, design or copyright, it is much easier to enforce should any alleged breach occur.

As can be seen from the Facebook dispute failure to record an idea can be costly…

Find out more about Hart Browns Commercial Business department

Tuesday, 11 January 2011

ex-BBC presenter wins ageism and victimisation claims

Today ex-BBC Countryfile presenter, Miriam O’Reilly won her claims of ageism and victimisation at London Central Employment Tribunal. The compensation to be awarded will be decided at another hearing in a few weeks time, however, a figure of around £100,000, including lost earnings and an amount for injury to feelings, is likely to be awarded.

Miriam O’Reilly, 53, was one of four female presenters who were dropped from Countryfile when it was moved it from Sunday mornings to a primetime slot early Sunday evenings. The others included Juliette Morris, Charlotte Smith and Michaela Strachan. The current Countryfile presenters are Matt Baker and Julia Bradbury and both are significantly younger than Miriam.

In its judgment, the tribunal said "if the claimant had been 10 to 15 years younger, she would have been given proper consideration to remain as a presenter of Countryfile. The discrimination was not justified. The wish to appeal to a primetime audience, including younger viewers, is a legitimate aim. however, we do not accept that it has been established that choosing younger presenters is required to appeal to such an audience."

The tribunal rejected the BBC's suggestion that it had devised and adopted proper criteria for choosing the new Countryfile presenters and said that the explanation of the selection process offered in evidence by the BBC was "complacent".

The tribunal also found that the decision which not to give Miriam O'Reilly any further writing work on Countryfile magazine was "an act of victimisation" resulting from "annoyance as to the allegations that [Miriam O’Reilly] was making".

This case is a reminder to even the most high profile employers that employers should ensure that clear, objective and non-discriminatory selection criteria should be used throughout all employment policies in order to reduce the risk of employment tribunal claims and promote equality in the workplace.

Find out more about how Hart Brown can help with a discrimination claim

Child Maintenance Enforcement Commission

The Daily Telegraph has reported that within the next few days, the DWP will be announcing proposals to charge parents for the services of CMEC (the Child Maintenance Enforcement Commission). CMEC is one of the “quangoes” the government is considering scrapping, with the service being taken under the wing of the DWP in order to save costs. It is thought that the DWP will be asking for the public’s views on charging parents for collecting child maintenance, including how much should be charged. In the meantime, let us know your first thoughts on the matter.

Find out more about Hart Brown's family department

Monday, 10 January 2011

UK house prices fell 1.3% in December 2010

Our solicitors comment on the BBC article "UK house prices fell 1.3% in December, Halifax says"

The article comes as no surprise as the last 2 or 3 months have seen pressure on prices. Clients of ours who sold in the late summer, only to lose their buyers and to re sell in November and December are having to take a reduced offer to re sell. Agents are desperate to keep buyers on board where matters have stagnated telling our sellers “you will not achieve this price in the current climate and for the foreseeable future”. Gazzundering, where buyers come in at the last minute requesting a price reduction for no reason other than the market suggests a reduction in value, is common place but does not seem to receive the press coverage expressing the out rage that accompanies the opposite, gazumping, when a seller ups the price at the last minute. Interestingly gazundering is seen as fair game but gazzumping as abhorrent.

There are no indicators as yet that the market is going to pick up at all from a price perspective in the coming 12 months and if anything is going to continue to slide downwards. This is positive from the point of view of first time buyers and those moving up market and so does not deserve the negative press that a sliding market receives. The negative press is generally generated by those having a vested interest in the market flying away upwards, estate agents and mortgage lenders.

Stability and volume is what most people in the interest would like to see.

Find out more about Hart Brown's Residential property team based in Surrey and South London

Prime Minister to talk jobs with big business

Is making it easier for small businesses to hire and fire staff going to help the economy and small businesses generally?

A common complaint by employers is that dismissing disruptive or not very competent staff or someone who does not fit into an organisation which in turn causes disharmony within the office is very difficult. There are lots of hoops to go through and whether you do it all correctly or not you can still be faced with a claim in the employment tribunal with its inherent costs. At the same time it is important that employees are given protection. Finding yourself unemployed (as so many have experienced in the last few years) is devastating to your self esteem, finances and life.

Working for an employer for many years only to be dismissed for no reason can’t be right either. Getting the balance therefore of protecting a business so that it can continue to employ people and generate income while protecting the employee’s rights is hard. It is difficult to see how requiring a fee to be paid when bringing a claim in the employment tribunal would make much difference other than assist the deficit!! Perhaps the tribunal should be much tougher when assessing a case in the early stages with a view to sifting out spurious claims. Maybe it should make more use of the requirement for a claimant to put funds into court where the claims appears weak and maybe tribunals should not allow fundamental changes to a claimant’s case late in the day. What do you think?

Read the article here
Find out more about Hart Brown's employment team in Guildford

Friday, 7 January 2011

Englands Cricket Victory

The longest running sagas of my professional career but at last completion has taken place. No, not a long winded property matter, but the winning of an Ashes series Down Under, the first such victory since I qualified with HB 25 years ago.

My presence in Australia over Christmas must be a major factor in this remarkable change of fortunes….

Roll on 2013 when what is likely to be an invigorated Aussie side comes to our shores to try and win the Ashes back

Author: David Knapp